REVIEW OF NEUROSTIMULATION FOR NEUROPATHIC FACIAL PAIN

  From the Summer 2007 TNALERT  
   
 

This review includes neurostimulation procedures for trigeminal neuropathic pain (TNP), anesthesia dolorosa (AD), post herpetic neuralgia, and occipital neuralgia. Neurostimulation is used for the conditions described below, but these procedures are not used to treat trigeminal neuralgia.

NOTE: Portions of this article are based on anecdotal information from patient calls and a TNA Sixth National Conference panel.

   
 

By Alana Greca, BSN, RN

Former TNA Director of Patient Support

At the TNA 6th national conference last fall, there were 5 sessions devoted to education and discussion about treatment for the constant burning pain associated with nerve damage or neuropathic pain. This review includes neurostimulation procedures for trigeminal neuropathic pain, trigeminal deaffrentation pain, anesthesia dolorosa (AD), post herpetic neuralgia, and occipital neuralgia.

NEUROPATHIC FACIAL PAIN DISORDERS

Neurosurgeon and member of the TNA Medical Advisory Board, Kim Burchiel, has proposed a classification system that divides neuropathic facial pain according to the cause of damage to the trigeminal nerve.

 OHSU Facial Pain Classification System

This classification system was used in the book, Striking Back, and will be used here to provide continuity in terminology. Please be aware that other medical providers may use different terms for the same problems.

Trigeminal neuropathic pain (TNP)---facial pain which is  due to unintentional injury from such things as:

  • facial trauma
  • dental procedure
  • complication of  sinus surgery or other ear, nose or throat operation
  • side effects of stroke or diabetes.

Symptoms:

  • if triggered, the pain is usually in the trigger area
  • pain described as constant, dull, burning, aching, or boring
  • numbness and tingling may also be present
  • intermittent sharp stabbing pain may also occur

http://www.spineuniverse.com/displayarticle.php/article391.html

Trigeminal deaffrentation pain (TDP)---This is pain that occurs when parts of the nerve are severely injured and have little or no function as a result of intentional injury.

TDP occurs as a complication from surgeries done to treat TN pain, such as:

  • Alcohol or glycerol injections
  • Radiofrequency lesioning
  • Balloon compression
  • Neurectomies
  • Radiosurgery

Deafferentation pain symptoms

Generally, continuous aching, burning quality – usually with numbness, tingling and/or hypersensitivity in the affected area. (“burning numbness.”)

In Striking Back! The Trigeminal Neuralgia and Face Pain Handbook, it is stated that “symptoms may even go beyond the trigeminal system….arm pain, shoulder pain, chest pain and even queasiness…”

Intermittent sensations like itching, crawling, pulling or pressure may occur.  If TN pain has been relieved, these symptoms will occur alone or in addition to TN pain, if the surgery is ineffective.

http://www.umanitoba.ca/cranial_nerves/trigeminal_neuralgia/manuscript/types.html

http://www.cedars-sinai.edu/3983.html

Anesthesia dolorosa

“…This is a seemingly impossible combination of both dense numbness and severe pain in the same area following an injury to that area.” There are several theories as to why pain would be felt in a profoundly numb area. The first is that somehow the touch nerve fibers were destroyed, but the pain fibers are still functioning. The second is that the brain center which monitors and interprets the nerve signals either remembers or substitutes signals when it is no longer is receiving impulses from the non-functioning nerve.

Facial Neuralgia Resources - AD

Center for Cranial Nerve Disorders - AD

Post herpetic neuralgia (PHN)--- This is pain which follows an attack of shingles (herpes zoster), and is a result of viral damage to the nerve. If it affects the glossopharyngeal nerve, it gives throat pain; hearing difficulties result if the aucoustic nerve is damaged; drooping or paralysis of the face may occur when the facial nerve is involved; damage to the trigeminal nerve (usually the first branch area) presents as facial pain.

Symptoms

  • Pain tends to be more constant than classic TN
  • different descriptions of pain---sharp & jabbing; burning pain; deep and aching, dull and borimg
  • Along with the pain there is often skin sensitivity and sometimes an itching or numb feeling.

Facial Neuralgia Resources - PHN

E-Medicine/Web MD - PHN

Mayo Clinic- PHN

http://www.ccjm.org/PDFFILES/Nagel7_07.pdf

Occipital Neuralgia

Although called a neuralgia, this disorder is actually related to nerve damage to the greater or lesser occipital nerves. It presents as one sided pain which begins at the back of the head and may then radiate up toward the forehead. The pain is described as a constant aching or throbbing, and does not have a trigger.

It can be the result of injury to the head or neck, or compression of the nerve by a tumor or blood vessel or neck lesion.

http://facial-neuralgia.org/conditions/occiptal.html

http://www.neurosurgerytoday.org/what/patient_e/occipital_neuralgia_06.asp

http://www.ninds.nih.gov/disorders/occipitalneuralgia/occipitalneuralgia.htm

DIAGNOSIS OF NEUROPATHIC FACIAL PAIN

It is important that neuropathic pain be differentiated from trigeminal neuralgia. Diagnosis is made based on:

Description of symptoms---the quality, characteristics, occurrence of pain is the most important means of accomplishing this.

Medical history prior to the onset of the pain should include one of the causative factors listed above for the neuropathic pain disorders.

SURGICAL TREATMENT FOR NEUROPATHIC FACIAL PAIN

The following surgical procedures are not usually done for neuropathic pain because they could increase the chance of complications, such as deaffrentation pain and anesthesia dolorosa:

  • Ablative or destructive surgeries which would cut or sever the trigeminal nerve Neurosurgeon and TNA Medical Advisory Board (MAB) co-chairman, Jeffrey Brown, at the recent Richmond regional conference advised anyone with facial pain to get a second opinion when cutting the nerve has been recommended to them. 
  • radiosurgery procedures, including: Gamma Knife, Cyber Knife, Novalis, etc.
  • percutaneous procedures (radiofrequency, balloon compression, glycerol injection)

NEUROSTIMULATION FOR NEUROPATHIC FACIAL PAIN

General Considerations

Each neurostimulation system consists of:

  • One or two leads or electrodes which deliver electrical stimulation to the targeted area
  • A wire which transfers the electrical impulses from the power source to the lead
  • A battery which generates the electrical stimulation

Most neurostimulator procedures are done in two stages:

  • The electrodes are implanted and connected via wire to an external battery in order to do a trial period, during which different settings (rate, intensity, etc.) are tried in order to determine the effectiveness of stimulation for pain management. This screening period will usually be between one and five days.
  • If the trial is considered successful, then the wire is placed under the skin and a pouch is created in the chest or abdomen to hold the battery. The battery area may be seen as a bulge under the skin, but should not be visible through clothing.

NOTE: A successful trial period confirms that stimulation may be helpful, but it does not assure that long term use of the stimulator will be successful.

http://www.medtronic.com/neuro/paintherapies/pain_treatment_ladder

Neurostimulation, is used to treat other conditions, such as Parkinson’s Disease, but this review will focus only on its use for facial pain management. Since it does not damage the nerve, it is ideal for those who already have nerve damage, and is generally used for those with chronic debilitating neuropathic facial pain who are not responsive to medical treatments. Neurostimulation therapy uses electrical stimulation to cause changes in the nervous system—impulses to block the pain messages to the brain.

The power source for the stimulator can be adjusted both during the trial period and after implantation through the use of an external programming device. Alterations in the strength and area of coverage can be made through changes in various pulse forms, amplitudes, pulse widths and frequencies.

http://www.answers.com/topic/neuromodulation?cat=health

 
 
 

BENEFITS OF NEUROSTIMULATION

  • The goal of stimulation is to reduce pain. Pain may be eliminated in some individuals, but a decrease in pain of 50% or more is considered a good response.
  • Increase activity level, independence, and/or quality of life
  • Reduce medication dosages or usage—particularly opioids
  • Reduce health cost

The advantages of using neurostimulation are that it is not destructive to the nerve, relatively safe, reversible (can be turned off and/or removed) and adjustable. Jaimie Henderson, neurosurgeon from Stanford University, says that he has found when pain relief is decreasing over time that he can improve pain control again by alternating different sets of parameters every few months. Several neurosurgeons have said that use has been discontinued in some cases, because pain has improved and stimulation was no longer needed.

PRIOR TO PROCEDURE

According to Konstantin Slavin, neurosurgeon at the University of Illinois of Chicago, a psychological evaluation is usually done on all stimulation candidates, in order to determine who will have the best chance of success and/or to find factors, such as untreated depression, which may negatively affect the outcome. Many emotional factors play a roe in pain management issues and a person’s expectations of the treatment can also influence outcome and should be discussed. If his/her goal is to pain free and return to work, but stimulation only provides a decrease in the pain level and allows for some increase in daily activities, then the person might be disappointed, even though his/her quality of life has been greatly enhanced.

http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/554865_print

http://www.clinicalpain.com/pt/re/clnjpain/abstract.00002508-200109000

INSURANCE COVERAGE

In all cases, it is necessary to apply for approval prior to the surgery

Even though deep brain stimulation has been performed for neuropathic pain in Europe and there are supportive articles, Dr. Ken Casey, co-chairman of the TNA Medical Advisory Board, advised attendees at a national conference session that it is not even considered for this use in the US. Therefore, insurance coverage is difficult to obtain.

Motor cortex stimulation is FDA approved for pain management, but not for facial pain, so the benefits listed above can be used as arguments for getting coverage for the procedure. At the 6th national conference, Dr. Casey and Dr. Henderson indicated that they are often successful in securing insurance payment when they present the surgery as an ultimate means of savings for the insurance company

COMPLICATIONS

Although most neurostimulation procedures are minimally invasive, and the potential complications for most are not as serious as other neurosurgeries, they still are surgical procedures and therefore, are not done as a first line treatment for neuropathic pain. Complications which are specific to each will be discussed under the appropriate heading, but general difficulties include:

  • Battery change—but newer power sources have rechargeable batteries
  • Infection of any insertion site or wire site
  • Electrode/wire displacement or breakage
  • Loss of benefit—diminished response with time
  • Skin erosion at power source site

POST IMPLANTATION CONSIDERATIONS

MRIs will not be done after deep brain stimulation because it might heat the wires and potentially cause brain injury. This same risk is not directly related to the other procedures, but MRIs are usually not done after any stimulators are implanted.

SURGICAL STIMULATOR PROCEDURES

The surgical procedures for neurostimulation include: spinal cord stimulation (SCS), occipital nerve stimulation (ONS), peripheral nerve stimulation (PNS), motor cortex stimulation (MCS), and deep brain stimulation (DBS). In treating facial neuropathic pain the method chosen would be the most appropriate, but least invasive procedure available

PERIPHERAL NERVE STIMULATION (PNS)

Prior to the procedure, a block with local anesthesia is often done to a specific nerve branch. Elimination of pain confirms that it is the nerve to be stimulated, but does not necessarily predict successful PNS.

Using local anesthetic, electrodes are injected under the skin of the face over the area of the nerve. Currently, it can only be used for first and second branch pain, but not for those with numbness or AD. Stimulation setting can be adjusted and the unit can be turned off and on as needed.

http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/554865_print

http://www.neurosurgery-online.com/pt/re/neurosurg/abstract.00006123-200407000

MOTOR CORTEX STIMULATION (MCS)

electrode (s) placed over the covering of the brain in the area at the top of the head where movement is controlled. It can be used for neuropathic pain in all 3 branches and with numbness, including anesthesia dolorosa.

  • Risks with motor cortex stimulation are as follows:
  • Bleeding inside the brain
  • Stimulation that results in pain

Seizure may be induced when the settings are being adjusted for the electrical stimulation, but it does not create epilepsy.

Motor cortex stimulation is thought to have a lower complication rate than deep brain stimulation.

http://www.aans.org/education/journal/neurosurgical/Dec06/21-6-7-1085.pdf

http://www.aans.org/education/journal/neurosurgical/Dec06/21-6-6-1074.pdf

http://www.aans.org/education/journal/neurosurgical/sep01/11-3-1.pdf

http://www.neurosurgery-online.com/pt/re/neurosurg/abstract

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites

DEEP BRAIN STIMULATION (DBS)

Surgery places electrode (s) inside the brain (the thalamus) utilizing a computerized guidance system.

DBS should not be done in those who have cardiac pacemakers.

Potential complications:

  • Any brain surgery carries a risk of cerebral hemorrhage - bleeding on the brain Impairment of some bodily functions
  • Stroke
  • Failure of the implant.

http://healthlink.mcw.edu/article/1031002638.html

http://www.spineuniverse.com/displayarticle.php/article2968.html

http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/554868_print

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites

http://www.springerlink.com/content/286146518m904035/

http://content.karger.com/ProdukteDB/produkte.asp?Doi=94958

http://www.blackwell-synergy.com

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites

OCCIPITAL NERVE STIMULATION (ONS)

Electrodes placed near the occipital nerves at the base of the head to provide stimulation to the occipital nerves

http://www.neurosurgery-online.com/pt/re/neurosurg/abstract

http://www.blackwell-synergy.com/doi/abs/10.1046/j.1525-1403.1999.00217.x

http://www.blackwell-synergy.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1094-7159.2004.04014.x

http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/554865_print

GASSERIAN GANGLION STIMULATION (GGS)

This type of stimulation has been tried for many years. An electrode is placed on the trigeminal ganglion, but it is difficult to keep the electrode in place; therefore, GGS is rarely used today.

http://www.ifess.org/INS_WSSFN_2005/INS/ABSTRACT/173.pdf

SPINAL CORD STIMULATION (SCS)

This treatment is rarely successful for effective facial impulses.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spinal_cord_stimulator

http://www.back.com/treatment-pain-neurostimulation.html

http://www.ans-medical.com/patients/WhatToExpectWithASCS/WhatToExpectwSCS.html

Posted 8-14-07